Buttermilk pie is my husband's favorite treat, so I make an effort every year to make it for him.
Here is what you need: (Note: this makes enough custard for two 8-inch pies)
1 - KitchenAid Stand Mixer (Highly recommend)
5 large farm eggs
1 T. lemon juice
3 c. sugar
1 T. Vanilla
4 T. unbleached flour
2 c. buttermilk
1 stick butter, melted
Dash of almond extract (optional)
Start by putting eggs in the KitchenAid Stand Mixer with the whisk attachment. Turn on and walk away - seriously. The secrect to a light buttermilk pie is light, fluffy eggs - which you won't get if you stand and watch them becaue you'll be tempted to stop them too early.
So, while you're eggs are beating, make the crust. Here's what you need for that:
1 1/2 c. pastry flour
1/2 c. oil
1/4 c. milk
dash of salt
Mix all together and form into a ball. Press out onto lightly greased pie pan and smooth out with hands to a uniform thickness. Use tip of a spoon to make pretty scalloped edges.
This recipe will do one 8-inch pie pan. I have tried to double this recipe before, but it's very hard to evenly divide the dough between the two pans and I just generally have not had good luck with trying to double this recipe. So, if you need two pies, just repeat. It should look like this:
This is a very good all-purpose crust. You can dress it up a bit by adding in a touch of cinnamon or sugar, depending on the pie your making. No need to pre-bake. I've never had trouble with it cooking perfectly and it always comes out light and buttery.
Now that you've got your crust ready, check your eggs. They should look like this:
Now, sift together the sugar and flour. Carefully add the remaining wet ingredients to the eggs, mixing just slightly. Add the flour mix in a third at a time, mixing in between.
Just a quick note about the almond extract: I stumbled upon this one day when I was just a hair short of Vanilla extract. I had almond extract and I was desperate - so I added just a little bit. It adds a nice nutty flavor the pie. But - if you want a more traditional buttermilk flavor, you can leave it out.
Then, divide the custard evenly between the two pie crusts and bake at 350 degrees for about an hour. My oven cooks a little slow, so I leave it in for an hour and ten minutes.
And now you should have:
Oh, so pretty!
Now, if for some reason you only want to make 1 pie and I bet you're thinking, "How do I divide 5 eggs in half?" Well, the number of eggs is really based on weight. My suggestion would be to cut it back to 3 eggs. I'd rather have it a little creamier than fall flat.
Normally, I point you to where I got the original recipe or idea, but this particular recipe is from an older version of Pinterest - my grandmother's recipe box.
It was the only thing of hers I really wanted after she passed because she was just an amazing cook. One of my fondest memories is visiting her house and smelling freshly baked pecan and lemon chess pies. Flipping through those carefully copied recipes brings back so many memories. Reading the notes she wrote to herself reveals her sense of humor as well as her practicality.
I also had a pair of German aunts that would send everyone in the family a huge box of Christmas cookies every year. And I'm talking huge - and inside was dozens of tea boxes filled with different kinds of cookies. I never knew how those two tiny German women drank that much tea each year!
Unfortunately, I don't know what happend to those recipes, but if I'm ever able to recreate them, that'd a crown jewel in my cooking crown. But - that's another blog for another time. :-)